The Meaning of Relics
The meaning of relics in the Middle Ages went far beyond their simple physical presence. These objects were invested with a particular sacredness due to their connection with holy figures, thus embodying a tangible connection between the divine and the earthly. Relics could take a variety of forms, from bone fragments to the personal belongings of saints and even items relating to crucial moments in Christ's life.
Their importance stems largely from the deep belief that relics served as direct intermediaries between believers and God. Apostles, martyrs and other holy figures were revered for their virtues and their closeness to divinity. Owning or venerating a relic was tantamount to establishing a spiritual connection with these figures, thus providing an opportunity to approach divine grace.
Believers attributed extraordinary powers to relics, considering them special channels for obtaining divine favors. Belief in the ability of relics to perform miracles was widespread. Miraculous healings, providential interventions, and other supernatural manifestations were associated with the presence or veneration of these holy objects. In this sense, relics became direct intercessors with God, embodying a source of miracles and blessings for those who fervently sought them.
Divine protection was also a crucial dimension of the meaning of the relics. Worshipers believed that proximity to these sacred objects conferred spiritual and physical security. Relics were seen as heavenly guardians, capable of averting calamities, ensuring prosperity and guaranteeing peace. Thus, owning a relic was often seen as an act of devotion and a source of comfort in a medieval world often marked by uncertainty and hardship.
The meaning of relics in the Middle Ages went far beyond the material framework. They represented a tangible interface between believers and the divine, offering hope, protection and a spiritual connection with revered holy figures. This deep understanding of the sacredness of relics played a major role in the spread and sustainability of the relic trade during this historical period.
The Relics Market
The relic market in the Middle Ages was a thriving business, woven into the very fabric of medieval life. Attracting a wide range of actors, from the simple pilgrim to the powerful ruler, this market was characterized by a complex dynamic of transactions, beliefs and the quest for prestige.
Pilgrims were one of the driving forces behind the relic market. Driven by ardent faith, they undertook often perilous journeys to holy places, in the hope of becoming closer to the deities or receiving special blessings. Relics, associated with these sacred places, became objects of desire for pilgrims, who were willing to spend considerably to acquire a fragment of the sacred to take home.
Monasteries and churches, as guardians of relics, actively participated in this trade. Possessing prestigious relics conferred a special status on these institutions, strengthening their spiritual influence and attracting more followers. Churches sometimes competed to acquire renowned relics, creating intense competition in the market.
Medieval fairs were essential hubs for the trade in relics. These events brought together merchants from far and wide, offering a variety of items, including relics. Pilgrims, attracted by the diversity of sacred objects presented, helped to make these fairs important platforms for reliquary transactions. Prices could vary considerably depending on the reputation of the relic, its rarity and the demand it generated.
Pilgrimages were also key moments in the relic market. Renowned pilgrimage sites attracted massive crowds, creating opportunities for relic sellers to profit from this influx of believers. Relics were often presented theatrically, during special ceremonies or temporary exhibitions, thus accentuating their mystical aura and stimulating demand.
The political dimension of the relics market cannot be neglected. Medieval rulers sought to accumulate prestigious relics, not only to strengthen their spiritual power, but also to establish their political authority. Possession of major relics became a key element in legitimizing royal power, and rulers sometimes competed or negotiated to obtain these revered objects.
The relic market in the Middle Ages was a complex ecosystem, where faith, economics and political power were intertwined. Fairs, pilgrimages and places of worship were the arenas where these transactions took place, creating a dynamic and sometimes controversial market, where the sacred mixed with the quest for profit and prestige.
The relics collected and venerated by medieval Europeans ranged from the mundane to the bizarre. The bones or body parts of saints and martyrs were always highly sought after. A church proudly displayed the brain of St. Peter until the relic was accidentally moved and revealed to be a piece of pumice.
The relics of Christ or the Virgin Mary were considered extremely valuable and included items such as the milk of the Virgin Mary, the teeth, hair and blood of Christ, pieces of the Cross and samples of the linen in which Christ was shrouded as a child. Many churches have even claimed to possess Christ's foreskin, cut off during his circumcision. The Turin Shroud, believed to be the burial shroud in which Christ was buried, is perhaps the most famous medieval relic of all.
In the Middle Ages, you could make a lot of money from bones, hair and nails, as long as they came from a saint. The measures taken by the Church against this trade were not very effective, especially since many of those who engaged in it were within its own ranks.
Political and Religious Powers
Relics, far from simply being objects of devotion, were powerful instruments used skillfully by medieval rulers to consolidate and legitimize their political as well as religious power. The acquisition of prestigious relics was a calculated strategy aimed at establishing a direct connection with divinity, strengthening the legitimacy of rule, and attracting divine favor.
Possession of a major relic was much more than just a display of personal piety for a medieval monarch. It was a tangible way to affirm the sacredness of his reign, to signal his divine blessing and, therefore, to strengthen his legitimacy in the eyes of the population. The relics of saints, apostles or Christ himself were considered symbols of spiritual power, granting the ruler quasi-divine authority.
Rivalry between monarchs to obtain the most prestigious relics was commonplace. Competitions to acquire renowned relics were often fierce, with rulers willing to spend considerable sums to acquire these sacred objects. These high-ranking relics were seen as rare and precious gems, capable of adding an aura of holiness to the royal court.
The quest for the most coveted relics was not only motivated by the personal piety of rulers, but also by skillful political calculation. Possession of prestigious relics could be used to rally popular support, strengthen the allegiance of local lords, and intimidate political adversaries. Medieval monarchs understood the symbolic power of relics in building and maintaining their authority.
Relics were often ostentatiously displayed during official ceremonies, thus reinforcing the link between the ruler and the deity in the eyes of the people. Rituals linked to relics became central elements of royal ceremonies, helping to establish an image of sacred power and project unquestioned legitimacy.
However, this strategic use of relics by medieval rulers was not without risks. Scandals linked to the counterfeiting of relics or the dishonest exploitation of the credulity of the faithful could have harmful consequences on the reputation of the sovereign and, by extension, on the stability of his reign.
Relics were powerful instruments in the hands of medieval rulers, skillfully used to consolidate their authority, enhance their legitimacy, and assert their direct connection to the divine. This strategic use of relics takes place in a context where politics and religion were closely intertwined, creating a powerful link between popular faith and monarchical power.
It was concerns about his finances that led the Byzantine emperor Baldwin II in the 13th century to take a rather unusual step. To find money, he sold Christ's crown of thorns, which he owned, to King Louis IX of France. Since then, the crown has been kept at the Sainte-Chapelle in Paris, the palace chapel of the former royal residence, and is one of the main relics of Christian churches. Among the Habsburgs, it was especially Rudolf IV who was a great collector of relics.
The trade in such important religious objects was frowned upon by the Church, which prohibited it throughout the Middle Ages. All that was permitted was the exchange of these objects, in exchange for prayers offered by monks and nuns, gifts or purchases from "non-believers" in order to give them to the Church. As these objects were valuable goods, it was customary to pass off transactions involving relics as donations or theft. It is true that many of these objects were in fact fakes. In the first half of the 15th century, for example, St. Bernard of Siena expressed the opinion that there were so many pieces of Christ's cross in circulation that twelve oxen could not carry them all.
It was especially the clergy who were active in the relics trade, because they had access to churches and monasteries and knew the value of the objects in question. However, it was not easy to price them, as there were few goods with which the relics could be compared. Ecclesiastical historians assume that the prices charged must have been "astronomical". For example, the bones of Saint Anthony were weighed for gold in the early Middle Ages. Indeed, the buyer did not want to commit a sin by underestimating the value of such a relic.
Reformation and Decline
The Protestant Reformation of the 16th century, led by prominent figures such as Martin Luther, profoundly influenced the way Western society viewed faith, religious practice, and, consequently, the trade in relics. This period of radical transformation had significant repercussions on the relics industry, leading to a marked decline in this centuries-old practice.
Reformers, like Martin Luther, challenged some of the main elements of traditional Catholic theology, including the veneration of relics. Luther openly criticized the idea that relics could serve as necessary intermediaries between believers and God. He challenged the validity of accumulating merit through the veneration of relics, emphasizing the notion of salvation through faith alone. This fundamental questioning undermined the very foundation of the trade in relics, which was based largely on the belief in their spiritual and saving power.
Reformers also denounced the use of relics for profit. They accused certain church leaders of taking advantage of the credulity of the faithful by selling relics or organizing lucrative pilgrimages. These criticisms were particularly virulent with regard to indulgences, certificates supposed to reduce the time spent by a person in purgatory in exchange for financial contributions.
Confiscations and bans from Reformed authorities and states that adhered to Reformation ideas contributed to the decline of the relic trade. Some governments, influenced by the new Protestant theology, banned the public veneration of relics, closed places of pilgrimage, and cracked down on those who continued to promote the practice. Relics, once considered spiritual treasures, were sometimes confiscated and destroyed.
At the same time, the Reformation brought significant changes to the religious mentality of the time. The focus on personal reading of the Bible, criticism of non-Scripture-based traditions, and emphasis on a personal relationship with God reoriented Christian piety. In this context, relics, as objects materializing spirituality, lost their importance.
The Protestant Reformation of the 16th century marked a decisive turning point in the history of the trade in relics. Criticisms from reformers, confiscations, bans and changes in mentality contributed to the gradual disappearance of this practice, ending centuries of veneration of relics as a spiritual commodity.
Peter Brown, The Cult of the Saints: Its Rise and Function in Latin Christianity (1981).
François Bovon, Les Reliques: Histoire, Signification et Enjeux (2006).
Jean-Marc Berthoud, Le culte des reliques en Occident du IVe au XIIe siècle (2004).
Richard W. Hoover, Holy Bones, Holy Dust: How Relics Shaped the History of Medieval Europe (2015).
Sophie Charlier, Le commerce des reliques au Moyen Âge, dans Les Études médiévales (2010).
David H. Williams, The Relic Trade in Medieval Europe: A Comprehensive Analysis (2012).
Michael E. Rubin, The Political Power of Relics in Medieval Europe, dans Journal of Medieval History (2011).
Jane P. Hargrove, Relics and Royal Authority: The Use of Sacred Objects in Medieval Monarchy, dans The Medieval Review (2012).
John G. Alexander, Relics and Power: The Role of Sacred Objects in Medieval European Politics (2009).
Thomas A. Fichtner, The Reformation and the Decline of Relic Veneration, dans Reformation Studies (2014).
Barbara D. Stabler, Luther's Challenge to Relic Worship and Its Impact on Medieval Devotion (2010).
Robert L. Harrington, From Relics to Reform: The Transformation of Religious Practices in Early Modern Europe (2018).
